Challenging Forgets: Unveiling the Worst-Case Forget Sets in Machine Unlearning

Chongyu Fan, Jiancheng Liu*, Alfred Hero, Sijia Liu ;

"The trustworthy machine learning (ML) community is increasingly recognizing the crucial need for models capable of selectively ‘unlearning’ data points after training. This leads to the problem of machine unlearning (), aiming to eliminate the influence of chosen data points on model performance, while still maintaining the model’s utility post-unlearning. Despite various methods for data influence erasure, evaluations have largely focused on random data forgetting, ignoring the vital inquiry into which subset should be chosen to truly gauge the authenticity of unlearning performance. To tackle this issue, we introduce a new evaluative angle for from an adversarial viewpoint. We propose identifying the data subset that presents the most significant challenge for influence erasure, i.e., pinpointing the worst-case forget set. Utilizing a bi-level optimization principle, we amplify unlearning challenges at the upper optimization level to emulate worst-case scenarios, while simultaneously engaging in standard training and unlearning at the lower level, achieving a balance between data influence erasure and model utility. Our proposal offers a worst-case evaluation of ’s resilience and effectiveness. Through extensive experiments across different datasets (including CIFAR-10, 100, CelebA, Tiny ImageNet, and ImageNet) and models (including both image classifiers and generative models), we expose critical pros and cons in existing (approximate) unlearning strategies. Our results illuminate the complex challenges of in practice, guiding the future development of more accurate and robust unlearning algorithms. The code and supplementary material (appendix) are available at https://github.com/OPTML-Group/Unlearn-WorstCase."